Abortion activists weaponize Texas pro-life law to censor critics who expose illegal abortion pills
Seeking to fine and silence pro-life activists using the new law for "noticing the obvious – abortion pills can be illegally trafficked – is like going after the person reporting a fire instead of the arsonist," defendant says.
Exultant after the Supreme Court eliminated federal abortion rights and returned the decision to the states, the pro-life movement has suffered repeated setbacks over the ensuing four years, often at the hands of voters in red states and their own putative allies.
Compounding their frustration with the Trump administration's refusal to reinstate in-person prescribing requirements for the abortion pill mifepristone, at least until a disputed safety review is completed, pro-life activists face litigation under a Texas law they championed yet has been weaponized against them by abortion rights activists.
Several Students for Life of America staffers, including President Kristan Hawkins, responded in court last week to a Texas mother's request for nearly $460,000 in damages against them for violating HB 7, which allows private citizens in the state to seek civil enforcement against those who play a role in making mifepristone available in Texas.
That's the same outsourced-enforcement mechanism that made SB 8, which pioneered a near-total abortion ban in Texas without a public official to enforce it, nearly invulnerable to legal challenge before the Supreme Court overturned federal abortion rights.
SB 8 took the idea from California environmental law, which pioneered the "private attorney general" approach to consumer protection. Citizen enforcers are known as "relators" acting on behalf of the government, as in federal legislation such as the False Claims Act.
The litigation is based on a disappearing Instagram post by Hawkins on March 23, which shows her, SFLA spokesperson Lydia Taylor Davis and the group's campus tour manager Jamie Curry standing on a sidewalk in Houston. Davis is interacting with her phone.
"Guess what we are doing? Ordering abortion pills undercover?" the caption reads. "Yep. Stay tuned."
The litigation also refers to a YouTube video that shows Hawkins "displaying an order confirmation" as she stands in the same location.
While this looks like "nothing more than a publicity stunt" intended to intimidate "physicians providing telemedicine abortion services to Texans," by making them wonder whether any given mifepristone request is in fact a sting operation, it "appears to violate the plain language" of HB 7, states the lawsuit by pseudonymous Maria Puerto.
She's represented by Amplify Legal, the litigation arm of Abortion in America, founded by the late Planned Parenthood President Cecile Richards. Her mother was former Texas Gov. Ann Richards, the last Democrat elected to that position until this month's midterms.
Seeking sanctions on SFLA staff "for noticing the obvious – abortion pills can be illegally trafficked – is like going after the person reporting a fire instead of the arsonist," Hawkins said in a statement through her lawyers at the Thomas More Society last week.
“Kristan Hawkins and her colleagues gathered evidence of an illegal trade and shared it with the public, investigative reporting the First Amendment protects," said their lawyer, Peter Breen. "This case is a patently meritless attempt to silence and cover up the truth that out-of-state interests are flooding Texas with abortion pills."
Mother's lawyers 'wrote our defense for us'
Under HB 7, "a person may not [...] mail, transport, deliver, prescribe, or provide an abortion-inducing drug in any matter to or from any person or location in this state," holding such individuals liable for violating the law or just intending to do so. It exempts women who use, obtain or seek abortion pills for their own use.
The law provides for at least $100,000 in damages for each violation, plus attorney's fees and costs, and doesn't require the "relator," the person bringing suit on behalf of the government, to have personally suffered from a defendant's conduct.
Puerto's sought-damages figure is the alleged "average cost of raising two children from birth to age 18 in the state of Texas," the Oct. 13 suit says. She blames SB 8, which took effect five years ago, for saddling her with two children she would have otherwise aborted.
The law only provides $10,000 of the sought damages for the relator, with the rest going to a charitable organization of that person's choice, meaning it couldn't come close to covering Puerto's childcare costs. Her lawyers at Amplify Legal said the rest would go to Jane’s Due Process, which helps abortion seekers in Texas circumvent the law.
She also seeks an injunction against the defendants, SFLA and "anyone in privity or acting in concert or participation with" them, to stop future undercover stings for mifepristone.
Puerto's suit names as defendants Hawkins, Davis, Curry and SFLA Texas regional coordinator Megan Roos, speculating that the latter was "involved in ordering the abortion pills that day and may be the individual who took the photograph" in the Instagram post, given other posts showing Roos in the same SFLA T-shirts for pro-life canvassing that day.
It asserts that the four "are not pregnant and were not pregnant" when the photo was taken, meaning they don't qualify for the exception and making it unclear whether they "engaged in fraudulent misrepresentation(s) to obtain the abortion pills." The suit cites Mother Jones reporting about Hawkins' alleged pseudonym in stings and Davis posing as a minor.
Amplify Legal "wrote our defense for us" by highlighting SFLA staff "weren’t pregnant, weren’t seeking an abortion, and were exposing abortion pill traffickers – precisely the conduct Texas’ abortion pill trafficking law says it does not reach," said Breen, the defense lawyer.
'Vague and fact-free' claims
The defendants' answer Nov. 9 challenges Puerto's "constitutional standing to seek a monetary award or an injunction," as she denied "any redressable injury" to herself from their alleged conduct and "alleges no concrete injury" to Texas as the law requires.
It asks the Harris County district court hearing the dispute to verify in chambers that Puerto exists, then confidentially disclose her "true name" to the defense. (Puerto's suit identifies her as a 26-year-old U.S. citizen who primarily speaks Spanish, raising one- and three-year-old children she had no "choice" but to carry under Texas law.)
The answer denies that Roos, the Texas coordinator, was with the SFLA group at the location in the photo that date or that she tried to acquire abortion pills or actually did so.
These allegations, including that she was campaigning that day for state GOP Rep. Briscoe Cain – also one of the lawyers for the SFLA defendants – are "no more than unreasoned conclusions and rank speculation" about Roos, with no specific facts articulated.
The answer says that "any otherwise-covered handling or possession of abortion-inducing drugs by any Defendant was conducted solely for the purpose of public advocacy, investigative journalism, or exposing illegal trafficking of abortion-inducing drugs into Texas," not to terminate a pregnancy or pass along pills to or from "any person or location."
It challenged Puerto's characterization of the so-called publicity stunt as violating the law.
"Ordering as part of a public demonstration is not itself an act enumerated in the statute" or even pleaded in the lawsuit as "providing" or "mailing" abortion drugs, the answer said, dismissing the lawsuit as a "vague and fact-free allegation."
Puerto "does not even attempt to show Defendants either intentionally prescribed, dispensed, or administered any abortion drug or that they did so with an intent to terminate a pregnancy," the answer says.
It seized on her failure to assess whether her $460,000 estimate for childrearing costs "reflects her costs or likely costs," and called her source – a Lending Tree study – an "unrigorous, non-peer reviewed study" that "uses modeling assumptions for a very different household than the one she describes," which invariably "inflates her estimated costs."
The Facts Inside Our Reporter's Notebook
Videos
Links
- voters in red states
- Trump administration's refusal to reinstate
- disputed safety review is completed
- Texas law they championed
- SB 8, which pioneered a near-total abortion ban
- SB 8 took the idea from California environmental law
- YouTube video
- lawsuit by pseudonymous Maria Puerto says
- Amplify Legal
- alleged "average cost of raising two children
- Mother Jones reporting
- defendants' answer Nov. 9