GOP legislation would let children, parents sue medical providers for gender transition 'harms'
Related legislation would withhold federal funds from K-12 schools that "affirm" gender identity or pressure parents to transition kids. Radical feminists who oppose transgender ideology face deplatforming by the "political tech juggernaut" behind Democratic campaigns.
The Facts Inside Our Reporter’s Notebook
- President Biden's LGBTQI+ executive order
- "central nervous system for practically all of Democratic politics"
- Protect Minors from Medical Malpractice Act
- failed Obamacare effort to withhold Medicaid funding
- Empower Parents to Protect Their Kids Act
- painful, lengthy and not fully reversible process
- "rapid-onset gender dysphoria"
- publicly mischaracterized the extent of corrections
- Institute for Comprehensive Gender Dysphoria Research,
- Emily Bazelon reported
- rush to medicalize gender dysphoria
- appeals court overturned a ruling
- girl who said Tavistock made her a "guinea pig"
- the clinic itself
- rebranding as Bonterra
- acceptable use policy
- "political tech juggernaut" for liberal campaigns and causes
- hate-crime "modifier" to a disorderly conduct charge
Defenders and opponents in the gender wars traded blows this week, with Republican lawmakers introducing legislation to counter President Biden's LGBTQI+ executive order, while left-leaning tech sites seem increasingly to deplatform dissident feminists who oppose transgender ideology.
The Protect Minors from Medical Malpractice Act, sponsored by Sen. Tom Cotton of Arkansas and Reps. Jim Banks of Indiana and Doug LaMalfa of California, would make medical practitioners liable for "any physical, psychological, emotional, or physiological harms" that result from gender-transition procedures on minors.
These include prescribing or administering puberty blockers or cross-sex hormones, or performing surgeries such as mastectomies and vaginoplasties.
The legislation gives minors and legal guardians the right to sue medical practitioners for transitions up to 30 years after the minors turn 18. They could seek declaratory or injunctive relief, compensatory and punitive damages, and attorney's fees.
The bills would apply to all transition procedures with an element of "interstate or foreign commerce," including digital communications, payments and the instruments used in surgery.
Taking a page from the failed Obamacare effort to withhold Medicaid funding from states that refused to expand the program, the legislation would revoke U.S. Health and Human Services funding from states that require practitioners to perform gender transitions.
The three lawmakers also introduced a related bill, the Empower Parents to Protect Their Kids Act, to withhold federal funding from K-12 schools that facilitate gender transitions, "affirm" a student's gender identity, hide that identity from the student's parents or encourage them to transition their child.
The Biden executive order promotes "irreversible and life-altering surgery for minors too young to apply for a learner’s permit," said Banks, chairman of the Republican Study Committee, in a press release.
"These procedure[s] lack any solid evidence and have been rejected by public health agencies around the world," he said, predicting "hundreds of thousands of Americans" will be "permanently scarred" by medical transitions in a decade. Cotton and LaMalfa emphasized the likelihood of resulting sterilization.
The medical malpractice bills recognize the phenomenon of "detransitioners" who give up their gender identities and return to identifying with their sex after they have undergone transitions, which can be a painful, lengthy and not fully reversible process.
Mainstream gender clinicians have only recently acknowledged the phenomenon of "rapid-onset gender dysphoria" described in 2018 by behavioral scientist Lisa Littman: adolescents, especially girls in the same friend group, suddenly identifying as the opposite sex due to "social influences."
Littman left Brown University after it publicly mischaracterized the extent of corrections in her peer-reviewed research. She's now president of the Institute for Comprehensive Gender Dysphoria Research, which she helped found last fall.
In a draft chapter on adolescents for the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) in December, seven clinicians and researchers cited "social influence" as a potential factor in gender transitions, New York Times Magazine's Emily Bazelon reported last week.
Months earlier, two WPATH board members and transgender women expressed concern to journalist Bari Weiss about the rush to medicalize gender dysphoria -- the default approach in so-called gender-affirming care -- noting transition can cause permanent sexual dysfunction in adolescents.
Erica Anderson, then at the University of California San Francisco’s Child and Adolescent Gender Clinic, said the "sloppy" failure to evaluate mental health would lead youth to regret their transitions. Marci Bowers, who performed transgender reality TV star Jazz Jennings's vaginoplasty, said recommending testosterone for girls with eating disorders after "one visit" is a "red flag."
The debate about youth transition is farther along in the U.K., where last fall an appeals court overturned a ruling against the Tavistock gender clinic that found minors cannot consent to puberty blockers under age 16.
Questioning the basis for gender identity in the law is apparently getting the Women's Liberation Front (WoLF) deplatformed by its customer relationship management provider.
EveryAction, which is rebranding as Bonterra, acquired WoLF's provider SalsaLabs a year ago and is now scrutinizing those clients for adherence to its acceptable use policy. Bloomberg calls the company, which also bought MobilizeAmerica, CyberGrants and Network for Good, a "political tech juggernaut" for liberal campaigns and causes.
In correspondence that WoLF shared with Just the News, EveryAction said it does not "support advocacy for women and girls' rights … at the expense of the LGBT community," implying it would not renew the gender-critical radical feminist group's SalsaLabs contract.
Meghan Apfelbaum, vice president of corporate strategy, pointed to a section of the policy that bans discrimination against "gender or identity expression."
WoLF Executive Director Mahri Irvine told Just the News on Wednesday that EveryAction didn't answer when she asked if it was accusing her group of discrimination against "trans-identified individuals." EveryAction didn't respond to a query from Just the News, and its website blocked an attempted second query.
It's a less severe possible outcome than a WoLF member faced last year in Madison, Wisconsin. The Dane County district attorney applied a hate-crime "modifier" to a disorderly conduct charge for Thistle Pettersen for posting gender-critical stickers around the city, with a potential sentence of 2 years in prison and $10,000 in fines. A judge dismissed both charges.