Families sue far-left states to stop penalizing religion, geography in school benefits and choice

Minnesota denies "subtraction and credit" tax benefit to families whose educational expenses are "too religious" as determined by one official, suit says. Another demands Vermont's oft-litigated town tuitioning program be available statewide.

Published: November 21, 2026 11:56pm

The Supreme Court has repeatedly told states in the past decade they cannot favor the secular over the religious, or a particular kind of religion but not another, in the provision of generally available public benefits, from school tuition assistance in rural areas and playground revamps to unemployment compensation tax exemptions.

Families in the upper Midwest and New England, a recurring target for religious discrimination claims in the provision of educational benefits, are going to their respective states' courts to secure the school-choice benefits they claim the courts have already granted them, one for explicitly religious reasons and the other on more novel grounds.

Minnesota fathers Nathan Colestock and Joseph Osburn argue the Land of 10,000 Lakes owes them the same "K12 Education Subtraction and Credit" for Christian curricula that it gives families for secular education, to "offset the cost of tutoring, textbooks, instructional materials, and enrichment classes," in a state tax court complaint.

"In every respect but one, both the Colestock and Osburn families are exactly who Minnesota’s tax education benefits were written for," yet the state disqualifies them solely "because their children’s education is Christian," violating the First and Fourteenth amendments and Minnesota Constitution's conscience clause, says their lawyers at Alliance Defending Freedom.

Five Vermont families are challenging the Green Mountain State's exclusion of them from its Reconstruction-era town tuitioning program, which gives families in areas without public schools money to spend on other education, on the basis that their home districts have public schools. Previous challenges have focused on religious exclusions in programs.

Their addresses doom their children to inferior education, according to the Vermont Superior Court complaint, citing independent research the families commissioned on academic outcomes for students eligible for town tuitioning versus those who aren't. The state constitution guarantees "substantial equality of educational opportunity" throughout the state.

Three of the five families, in fact, want to put their kids in different public schools, their lawyers at the Liberty Justice Center note. Their home districts suffer from mediocre academics, lack of accelerated programs, disruptive environments, few extracurricular options and special education shortfalls, the complaint alleges.

A negative outcome in court for either Minnesota or Vermont could prompt bureaucrats and lawmakers to attempt an end-run, as Maine did when SCOTUS agreed to review its exclusion of "sectarian" schools from its own town tuitioning program, a restriction subsequently struck down.

The Legislature amended the Maine Human Rights Act to force religious schools to choose between keeping their sexual-orientation and gender-identity exemptions under MHRA and participating in the town tuitioning program.

Bangor Christian Schools' lawyers at the First Liberty Institute pledged to appeal to SCOTUS this summer when the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals refused to strike down the Legislature's so-called poison pill.

Revenue commissioner gets to decide what is 'too religious' to qualify

When SCOTUS last year ruled against Wisconsin's designation of Catholic Charities as a secular entity for tax purposes – on the basis that it serves everyone, not just Catholics – the precedent cited the high court's prior ruling against Maine's favoritism for "more watered down" religious education in town tuitioning, as Justice Samuel Alito described it.

Just as Maine deprived religiously fervent families of access to taxpayer dollars they themselves were still forced to pay, Minnesota compels Colestock and Osburn to "strip the faith that animates their lives from their children's education" to be treated the same as other parents who lower their taxable income by claiming credits for educational expenses, the suit says.

In a separate filing, they ask the tax court, which "lacks original jurisdiction to decide constitutional questions," to refer the case to a state district court to authorize the former to evaluate the state and federal constitutional questions.

Between the two fathers, they have six children old enough to "receive qualifying K12 education-related expenses" and four more too young to attend school currently.

They seek the taxable-income subtraction – $1,625 per K-6 child and $2,500 per grade 7-12 child – which the U.S. Supreme Court upheld against an Establishment Clause challenge in 1983, and a separate "refundable credit" of 75% of qualifying expenses up to $1,500 per child for earners below a certain income.

Guidance by Revenue Commissioner Paul Marquart, the defendant, puts few non-religious limits on what parents can claim as educational expenses, with even "field trips" and musical instruments covered but not athletic expenses, the suit says. It specifically excludes materials "primarily religious in nature" from approved homeschooling expenses.

Being ineligible for the benefits means Colestock, a pastor, cannot afford theater, "tumbling" and athletics for his kids, and Osburn, who also works for a Christian ministry, cannot afford pottery classes, math tutoring and gymnastics for his kids, or to pay for his youngest to attend the classical Christian academy his siblings attend.

Because they refuse to deceive the state by claiming their expenses are unrelated to teaching "religious tenets, doctrines, or worship," even if the state might view some as secular, they are deprived the same benefits as other parents, the suit says.

The state violates their constitutional free exercise of religion and due process, including the religious upbringing of their children, through a law that is not neutral or generally applicable because it grants the tax commissioner discretion to determine what is "too religious" to be covered, the fathers argue.

They seek only injunctions against the state denying or conditioning the benefits on "removing religion from otherwise-qualifying educational materials, fees, or tuition," and nominal but not compensatory damages.

'Substantially below proficient' more common without school choice

The Vermont litigation seeking school choice statewide, via town tuitioning, includes maps that show what the plaintiffs' school districts look like compared to their peers with access to town tuitioning when it comes to academic performance. The former have higher percentages of "substantially below proficient" on state competency exams and math.

A study by the Friedman Foundation, named after the pioneering free-market economist, found school choice in the Vermont context has far greater influence on standardized test scores than poverty, urbanization or per-pupil spending, according to the suit. 

In another foundation report examining a dozen "gold standard" studies, none found "access to independent schools had a negative impact on student academic achievement."

The plaintiffs seek injunctions against the geography-based exclusion rule.

Unlock unlimited access

  • No Ads Within Stories
  • No Autoplay Videos
  • VIP access to exclusive Just the News newsmaker events hosted by John Solomon and his team.
  • Support the investigative reporting and honest news presentation you've come to enjoy from Just the News.